Skip to content 
Table of Contents
Are you trying to choose a heating system for your home? You’re not alone in wondering about heat pump vs gas boiler options. With the UK government pushing greener energy and offering schemes like the Boiler Upgrade Scheme, more homeowners are asking: Should I get a heat pump or stick with a gas boiler?
This guide covers everything you need to know. We’ll look at heat pump vs gas boiler efficiency, running costs, installation, and long-term savings for UK homes. Ready to find your perfect heating solution?
What is a Heat Pump?
Have you ever been curious about how a heat pump actually works? It’s cleverly simple. A heat pump extracts thermal energy from the air (that’s your air source heat pump) or ground (ground source heat pump). Then it uses electricity to transfer that heat into your home.
The impressive thing is that heat pumps run on electricity but deliver around 3 to 4 kWh of heat for every 1 kWh they use. This is one of the main reasons why heat pumps are more energy saving than gas boilers.
Air Source Heat Pump Grants
What is a Gas Boiler?
However, the gas boilers work quite differently from heat pumps. A gas boiler burns natural gas to heat water and warm your home.
Modern A-rated gas boilers reach about 90% efficiency. You’ll find combi boilers, conventional boilers, and system boilers in most UK homes.
Efficiency Comparison: Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler
So, which heating system wins on efficiency? The numbers might surprise you:
- Heat pump efficiency: Up to 300-400% (COP 3-4)
- Gas boiler efficiency: Around 90% (A-rated)
Heat pumps are generally much more efficient than gas boilers. Think about it – a heat pump system provides 3-4 times more heat for every unit of electricity used. Meanwhile, gas boilers lose about 10% of heat through the flue.
When comparing gas boiler vs heat pump efficiency, heat pumps are around 3 times more efficient. That’s quite a difference, isn’t it?
Running Cost: Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler UK
But what about your monthly bills? Let’s break down the real costs.
Heat Pump Running Costs
The running cost of your heat pump depends on electricity prices. Here’s what you can expect:
- Electricity costs: ~30p/kWh (standard rate)
- Monthly electricity usage: 400–700 kWh
- Monthly cost: ~£120–£210
Want to cut these costs? Using a heat pump with solar panels makes a huge difference.
Gas Boiler Running Costs
Gas costs look like this:
- Gas price: ~8p/kWh
- Average winter usage: 1,000–1,500 kWh/month
- Monthly cost: ~£80–£120
So gas boilers are usually cheaper to run. But not by much when you use heat pumps efficiently. Here’s something interesting – heat pumps run more steadily while gas boilers work in bursts.
Installation Cost: Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler
What about upfront costs? There’s quite a difference here.
Heat Pump Installation
Getting a heat pump installed costs more initially:
- Installation cost of a heat pump: £7,000–£15,000 (before grants)
- Boiler Upgrade Scheme grants: Up to £7,500
- Final cost after grant: £2,500–£7,500
Installing a ground source heat pump costs even more (~£20,000+). Air source heat pump installation is quicker but still more involved than gas boiler work.
Gas Boiler Installation
Gas boiler installation is simpler:
- Gas boiler installation: £2,500–£4,000
- Some local support schemes may help
Much more straightforward, wouldn’t you say?
Lifespan and Maintenance
How long will your heating system last? This affects your long-term costs:
- Heat pumps: 15–20 years (with low maintenance)
- Gas boilers: 10–15 years (need annual servicing)
Heat pumps do need adequate space and good insulation. Is your home suitable for a heat pump? You’ll need a well-sealed property. Ideally, with underfloor heating or oversized radiators. Without these, your heat pump would work harder and cost more.
Pros and Cons: Heat Pump vs Gas Boiler
Let’s weigh up the benefits and drawbacks.
Heat Pump Benefits
- Lower carbon emissions
- Heat pumps have a lower lifetime cost
- Can provide both heating and hot water
- Works great with solar panels
- Eligible for heat pump grants
Heat Pump Drawbacks
- Higher upfront installation cost
- May need property adjustments
- Why is your air source heat pump expensive to run? Usually poor insulation or wrong sizing
Gas Boiler Benefits
- Lower initial cost
- Familiar technology
- Quicker and easier to install
Gas Boiler Drawbacks
- Higher carbon emissions
- Less efficient overall
- Subject to future fuel price rises
Considering a pump vs gas boiler comparison? Your choice depends on budget, property type, and sustainability goals.
Is Your Home Suitable for a Heat Pump?
Not every home is ready for a heat pump to be installed right away. You should check:
- Insulation and airtightness quality
- Radiator and pipe sizing
- Outdoor space for air source heat pump units
Can’t make the full switch yet? You might explore a hybrid system – a gas boiler with a heat pump working together.
Long-Term Savings & Environmental Impact
A heat pump would cost more upfront. But can it save money over time? Yes, through:
- Lower energy costs
- Reduced maintenance needs
- Government grants
- Increased home value
What about the environment? Heat pumps are generally the greener choice. Switching from gas boilers to heat pumps alone significantly cuts household emissions.
Final Verdict: Heat Pump or a Boiler?
So, which should you choose? If you have a limited budget, need an immediate replacement and your home isn’t ready for a heat pump system. You should consider getting a boiler installed at your property.
Get a heat pump if you want long-term efficiency and savings. You can access the Boiler Upgrade Scheme, and you want to reduce your carbon footprint. As a plus, you can pair your heat pump with solar panels to cut running costs even more.
Frequently Asked Questions
Your air source heat pump might cost too much because of poor insulation, undersized radiators, or incorrect system sizing.
Between 400–700 kWh monthly, depending on home size and insulation. Solar panels can reduce this substantially.
For efficiency and emissions – yes. But you must consider costs and whether your home is suitable for a heat pump.
- Heat pump installation: 2–5 days
- Gas boiler installation: 1–2 days
Yes, but check if your home is suitable first. You’ll need good insulation, proper radiator sizing, and outdoor space.
